DEBATE The welfare of the child
نویسندگان
چکیده
The regulation of assisted conception has been a contentious issue for many years and the debate shows no sign of approaching a conclusion. New reproductive technologies are being developed so rapidly that they are outstripping the provisions of the few legal frameworks that have been devised to regulate them (Ohl et al., 1996). Legislators have raised doubts as to whether any ‘single piece of primary legislation will ever be sufficient of itself to deal with such a complex area and with such fast-moving technology’ (Jowell, 1996). Year on year, fresh issues arise and are featured prominently in the media and academic journals. Lurid headlines follow reports of women being implanted with the ‘wrong’ embryo (Rogers, 1994), the misappropriation of embryos (Goodwin, 1995), women psychologically damaged by being reduced to baby making machines (Hunt, 1996) and lesbian women having ‘do-it-yourself’ babies (Rayner, 1997). Fresh controversy has been aroused by reports of the posthumous retrieval of gametes. In the UK, successful posthumous gamete retrieval has been accompanied by sceptical reporting (Ahuja et al., 1997a) and in the US, the absence of clear legal or ethical frameworks has been noted (Ohl et al., 1996). In sharp contrast to countries where assisted conception services are not subject to formal legislation and regulation, the UK position is clearly set out in Schedule 3 of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 1990 (hereafter called the Act). The Act came into force after wide public consultation and a government appointed Committee of Inquiry into Human Fertilisation and Embryology. After due consideration, the Report of the Committee expressed ‘grave misgivings’ about the posthumous use of gametes because this ‘may give rise to profound psychological problems for the child and the mother’ (Warnock, 1984, p. 18). However the report made no recommendation for action, stating instead that ‘posthumous use of gametes is a practice which we feel should be actively discouraged’ (Warnock, 1984, p. 55). Accordingly, the Act did not prohibit the retrieval and storage of such gametes, it added a proviso: the effective consent of the originator was required
منابع مشابه
Defining and categorizing the child welfare target group in Iran according to experts, laws, and policies
Abstract Introduction: Nowadays the concept of the child welfare system is defined in different countries due to the role of government and society in providing an appropriate context for the comprehensive development of children. The main role of the child welfare system is to ensure the safety and wellbeing of children and adolescents whose families do not meet or protect their needs. Also, ...
متن کاملDefining and categorizing the child welfare target group in Iran according to experts, laws, and policies
Abstract Introduction: Nowadays the concept of the child welfare system is defined in different countries due to the role of government and society in providing an appropriate context for the comprehensive development of children. The main role of the child welfare system is to ensure the safety and wellbeing of children and adolescents whose families do not meet or protect their needs. Also, ...
متن کاملAccess to Fertility Treatments for Homosexual and Unmarried Persons, through Iranian Law and Islamic Perspective
Background A family traditionally consisted of a married man, his wife, and their children. The new reproductive technologies including use of the third party as egg, sperm and embryo donation and also surrogacy have changed the traditional meanings of lineage, ancestry and family. The increasing number of lesbians and gays in addition to single women requesting fertility treatment from IVF cen...
متن کاملPrevalence and Causes of Neonatal Mortality in Hormozgan Province, Southern Iran
Infant health care should be one of the first and most important tasks of every nation and one of the main programs of any government, because children, as a vulnerable group, have a special place in health services . Based on the findings, the number of live births in 2014 and 2015 was 39627 and 41575, respectively. The number of neonatal deaths in 2014 was 12.5%̧ while it was 10.5% in 2015. Th...
متن کاملI-15: Offering Fertility Services to Whom? With Specific Regards to The Welfare of The Child
متن کامل
Faranak Parent-Child Mother Goose Program: Impact on Mother-Child Relationship for Mothers of Preschool Hearing Impaired Children
Objectives: The parent-child relationship is one of the strongest predictors of a child’s adjustment during adulthood. Many hearing-impaired children have normal hearing families, and this issue adversely affects the parent-child relationship; however, studies on interventions have focused on high-risk clinical specimens. Methods: The effect of the Faranak parent-child program (Persian v...
متن کامل